As of August 2018, we are no longer taking custom cookie orders. 

Let us help you celebrate your best. day. ever! Whether you'd like cookie favors for your guests or you are forgoing the traditional wedding cake with a dessert buffet, we have many options to help make your day perfect. The best part about our cookies? They are completely customizable to your day and they taste delicious too. 

Cookie Buffets

Cookies Only

Cookies are the main event! This cookie buffet option includes a mix of mini and small decorated cookies and includes up to 2 different sugar cookie flavors and up to 3 colors of icing.
Minimum 50 guests.

$3.75/guest for the first 150 guests, $3.00/additional guest

Interested in still having a small cutting cake?
Small 6" 2-layer cookie cake for $20

Cookie Buffet Minis by @cookiesbykatewi
Cookie Buffet Minis

Recommended for weddings that will have a dessert buffet with at least 3 other desserts or with a cake as the main dessert.
Minimum order 50 cookies.

Minis: 2 mini decorated cookies for every guest (300 cookies for 150 guests), $0.75/cookie
Smalls: 1 small decorated cookie for every 2 guests (75 cookies for 150 guests), $2.25/cookie


Wisconsin Bride magazine's "Favorite New Favor" in 2017

Packaged Wedding Favor with Paper Bag Topper by @cookiesbykatewi
Packaged Wedding Favor with Paper Bag Topper

Custom cookies are great wedding favors because they give your guest a sweet treat that allows you to share a bit of yourselves. Some couples prefer simpler designs like a monogram or the date of the wedding, others go with a design of a common hobby or sports teams. The possibilities are endless!

Packaged medium-sized cookies wrapped in ribbon or heat sealed (topped with a paper bag topper or not). Designs can include up to 4 colors (add $0.25/cookie for each additional color). Minimum order is 2 dozen packaged cookies.

24-49 packaged cookies $4.25/cookie
50-149 packaged cookies $4.00/cookie
150-249 packaged cookies $3.75/cookie
250+ packaged cookies $3.50/cookie

Packaged favors also make a great addition in hotel welcome bags!


Samples, Consultations, and Ordering

Interested in having our cookies at your wedding? Please start by filling out an order request form or email us at We are happy to meet with couples in person for a consultation or correspond through email or telephone. Free samples are also available upon request after the consultation.

For additional information about our ordering and payment information, please visit the info page.